Prefer to listen?
Click below to check out The Uncommon Career Podcast,  Episode #157

In interviews, do you use the STAR Method? It's not a problem in and of itself – but what if I tell you that you're missing tons of opportunities with it? Not because it's wrong, but because it's lacking.

The structure is good, the flow is well. But when all you do is tell them how you did XYZ for ABC, you're only saying what you did in a certain situation (that may only be present in the previous company) – not how you operate. Not how you came to that result. 

So STAR isn't wrong, but when it becomes your entire strategy, something critical gets lost. And that missing piece is often the difference between “That’s impressive” and “We need to hire this person.”

If you're having a little trouble with the verbiage or positioning in a way that gets you confident for interviews, come chat with me on LinkedIn! I'll be glad to send some resources over.

Listen on your favorite podcast app:

Why STAR Alone Isn’t Converting

The STAR method walks you through situation, task, action, result. It gives a logical sequence. It keeps your answer organized, but there is a depth problem to it.

As mentioned earlier, when you rely solely on STAR, you’re primarily describing what you did. The employer hears a chronological story. What they don’t fully hear is how you think.

And when that thinking isn’t explicit, they’re forced to fill in the gaps.

They start building mental bridges:

• Can this result be replicated in our current environment?

• Was that success tied to a different market condition or system?

• Were those circumstances unusually favorable?

• Would this person achieve the same outcome here, now, with us?

When hiring leaders have to do that mental work, uncertainty increases. And uncertainty rarely leads to bold offers.

The outcome begins to look serendipitous rather than strategic.

You’re Not Selling an Example – You’re Selling a Pattern

Take note of this: high-level hiring decisions aren’t about isolated wins. They’re about repeatable capability.

If your story sounds like a one-off success, it becomes impressive but risky. If your story demonstrates a pattern of thinking that produces results across contexts, it becomes powerful.

That shift requires going beyond what happened and articulating the mechanisms behind it.

Instead of stopping at action and result, the goal is to show that you are the common denominator. Not the environment. Not the timing. Not the team composition. You.

When you do that, employers stop wondering if you can recreate success. They start assuming you will.

Elevation One – Speak in Systems and Frameworks

One of the most powerful shifts you can take away is moving from describing events to describing processes. Over time, you develop patterns. You see recurring themes. You instinctively know what steps tend to move projects forward. But because this thinking feels obvious to you, it often goes unsaid.

When you articulate your framework, everything changes.

Instead of “I handled this project,” it becomes “In situations like this, I typically follow a three-step approach.”

This communicates:

• You recognize patterns across different scenarios

• You’ve built repeatable processes, not just reactions

• Your success is rooted in structured thinking

• You can apply this approach in new environments

Now the value isn’t tied to one company. It’s tied to how you operate.

Elevation Two – Share the Thinking Before the Action

The STAR method jumps straight into action. But before you acted, you were evaluating.

You were weighing trade-offs, assessing risk. prioritizing, and making decisions internally that shaped everything that followed.

That invisible thinking is often where your highest value lives.

When you begin to share:

• What factors you considered before choosing your approach

• What alternatives you ruled out and why

• What risks you identified early

• What assumptions you validated before acting

You transform your answer from descriptive to strategic.

This is especially critical for leaders. Decision-making depth signals readiness for greater responsibility. When that thinking is clear, the hiring leader no longer has to guess at your judgment.

Elevation Three – Highlight Real-Time Adjustments

Most stories are told cleanly. Step A led to Step B led to Step C. But real leadership rarely unfolds that neatly.

Budgets shift. Priorities change. Senior leaders pivot. New information surfaces mid-stream.

When you share how you adapted in real time, you demonstrate resilience and agility.

This might include:

• Reworking strategy when constraints changed

• Managing competing priorities without losing momentum

• Coaching team members through resistance

• Reframing objectives when external conditions shifted

It is these moments reveal depth behind your results. They show you don’t just execute a plan – you steer through complexity and adaptive mental processes.

And complexity is where senior roles live. 

Why This Changes Compensation Outcomes

Lastly, remember this bit... 

When a hiring leader believes your impact was situational, they negotiate cautiously. When they believe your thinking is portable and scalable, they negotiate competitively. That’s the difference between describing work and positioning value.

Sometimes, DIY-ing this is no trouble for professionals. But, if you're looking for expert advice and a feedback loop that completes not only your brand, but strategy, value, and high-impact shift in an hour and a half? Then check out the intensive and see if that's something you'd like to do.

When your answers clearly communicate that you are the strategic engine behind results, compensation shifts reflect that belief.

And that belief is built through how you articulate your thinking, not just your achievements.

If this sparked an “Oh, I’ve been leaving that out” realization, that’s a powerful place to start. The shift isn’t about abandoning structure. It’s about enriching it.

Keep the flow. Elevate the depth.

When you move beyond reporting what you did and start revealing how you think, offers don’t just come faster – they come stronger.